Kamry--Some people won't ever buy from someone without the Level 1 verified (which requires the facebook or twitter) but by doing phone and paypal verification, you have done everything you can at this point as a starting seller. Once you have started selling more and getting positive feedback, you can eventually get your sellers wings and that will help more people bid too. I don't have social media accounts either due to the security nature of my job (so can never be Verified Level 1), but haven't had too much trouble. Be a good trusted seller and over time your reputation speaks for itself.
Actually a level 1 verification means nothing to me, I see & report kids on here all the time that are "verified"! I go more by feedback and just the vibe I get when I read the auction! This one seems legit so, I'm F&W & possibly bidding! Don't worry, once you get a little feedback you'll be okay! Good luck & welcome!