Wow, why would you bid on something you have already decided isn't going to work. I have just listened to both of them and they play well. Plus just looking at the disc I can see no scratches. I am an honest seller or I wouldn't have the feedback I do. If i ever gave away a disc that didn't work i would expect the buyer to email me and I would return the credits. This is not the case with these cds, they are in pristine shape.