"Overall "positive" experience. Howe ... " (more)ver some issues. I would have to say this came in fair, to almost poor condition. There are finger smudges on the disc looks like a little kid handled the game, and the case does not even close because it is broken. The front and back of the game case also has some scuff marks on it. Definitely fair to poor condition, but I can't complain because the smudges on the disc I can clean easily, and I can get a new case for it.